Was Thistleclaw really evil? His mentor, Adderfang, was a battle-hungry warrior and he had some WindClan blood in him. He did have ambition from the start, but maybe having Adderfang as his mentor and not being pureblood might have turned him from mildly ambitious kit into arrogant, bloodthirsty warrior.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: hollyleap,

Isn't Thistle pure-blood? And yeah i partially agree with you. Thistleclaw was VERY ambitious since he was a kit, we could see that. but on the other hand if he was taught by tawnyspots or Sunfall, he might've been a bit like Blackstar. i dunno, just my opinion

He wasn't pureblood. His father, Windflight, was part WindClan and part ThunderClan.

I think Shadowscar is right...he would've been like Blackstar. But Thistleclaw isn't really that evil..he wasn't really bloodthirsty and he didn't kill any cats in my opinion

I dont know but tigerstar is evil because of him

Thistleclaw is evil but it is just because he has wind clan blood, was to ambitious and had Adderfang for a menor.

Yes. Thistleclaw was evil. It wasn't Adderfang's fault either.
Adderfang was a good, loyal Thunderclan warrior. It was
Thistleclaw's fault that Tigerclaw/star was evil as well.
So it's pretty much Thistleclaw's fault that Bluestar went crazy,
Stonefur's death, that huge battle between all of the clans,
that Firestar lost a life from battling with Scourge and that Whitestorm is dead. There's probably more deaths that are Thsitleclaw's fault, but i can't think of them right now.