I mean, think about it. She did kill Ashfur, and she said that she'd kill again if she had to. It doesn't say if she went to Starclan or the Dark Forest, so does that mean that the Erins still don't know? Personally, I never liked her. She was too bossy.
So what do you guys think about her?
~ ♥ Crookedstar ♥ Ashfur ♥ ~ If you touch either one of them I won't give you a brownie! I HAVE AN OBSESSION WITH GRAY PELTS ON CATS, DEAL WITH IT [Dealt with! - WCM] My kits- Stormkit, Breezekit, Blizzardkit, Smokekit, Moonkit, Wolfkit, Daisykit.
I mean, think about it. She did kill Ashfur, and she said that she'd kill again if she had to. It doesn't say if she went to Starclan or the Dark Forest, so does that mean that the Erins still don't know? Personally, I never liked her. She was too bossy.
So what do you guys think about her?
The Erins don't say if she went to StarClan or the Dark Forest because she's probably still alive in the tunnels that had "killed" her.
Hollyleaf felt that none of ThunderClan understood her, and she couldn't believe that she was the result of a broken part of the warrior code. So she probably tried to erase her past by killing Leafpool, which she didn't succeed in.
And as for the killing Ashfur, she felt that that time was not the right time for the Clans to know about her real mother and father, whereas Ashfur would've told at the Gathering.
When she felt that she was ready, she spoke at the Gathering herself.
I'll admit that I'm really not a Hollyleaf fan, but I can understand all (or most) of her actions.
I don't really like Hollyleaf, but I don't think that she's evil. I tink that she's almost evil, but she's not quite evil. (In my opinion) I sort of liked her when she was a kit and a young apprentice, but she wasn't my faviourite.
SunsetClan Forever! Squirrelflight,Feathertail and Honeyfern are awesome!
Hollyleaf is not evil, or anywhere near it. Vicky herself said that Hollyleaf's just "misguided and desperate" but not evil.
She killed Ashfur because she thought she and her brothers were Rouges. She figured if thunderclan found out, they'd kick her and her siblings out of camp for not being Clan-born.
But when Hollyleaf found out the truth of her heritage, it was then she realized she killed Ashfur for nothing, as she thought, because her parents had broken the warrior code. So, she took it upon herself to do what Ashfur was going to do, and revealed the secret herself, since she felt the warrior code was dead, and Thunderclan should not live in lies anymore.
Yellowfang's personal grandmother Royally hate Spottedleaf, Goosefeather.
Hollyleafs not evil just confused and deperate lost.She not dead so thats doesnt call for naything but she not a bad cat even if she killed ashfur.
O o okay yeah im a er a silver bengal cat thats right look it up. Sadly there not profile picture that looks close to it. so i went with ** cat above or somewere okay look it up.i loaded with drama so be were. yeah im kidding but im so board and plainly writing i should get a life but i dont feel like it. I ish a silver bengal cat..... wait i says that already!!!! oh yeah you know what you should try UNICORN JUICE!!!!!!! its not wut you think O o btw im a she cat for all u peeps out there oy and im on team jayfeather and lionheart!!!!!!!!
When she found out Squirrelflight wasn't her mother, and Brambleclaw wasn't her dad, she jumped on the cyco train! Excuse me from my spelling... Anyways, I think it was kinda pointless for her to kill Ashfur, because he was about to announce it at the gathering, she kills him to stop him, she blurts it out at the gathering anyway. Pointless!
[[ Oops! Please do not spam. ]]This message has been edited. Last edited by: Matthew - Moderator,
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ My time is about three hours before game time okizay?? *How is icey currently? : Foot injury... "Join Dwindleclan!" "Join Nightpack!" @@@ HEY YOU GUYS!! I'm really sorry if I don't post consistently, I promise I haven't deserted you!@@@
Originally posted by Sheepwhisker: I mean, think about it. She did kill Ashfur, and she said that she'd kill again if she had to. It doesn't say if she went to Starclan or the Dark Forest, so does that mean that the Erins still don't know? Personally, I never liked her. She was too bossy.
So what do you guys think about her?
Wait, wasn't that Squrrielflight??? Who killed Ashfur?This message has been edited. Last edited by: Zc2017,
Call me Redtalon. "Well, I'm more lopsided than a one-legged badger. I think I'll have to settle for hunting stupid mice. They won't stand a chance. I shall just wander up to them and sit on them till they surrender." (Graypaw, Into the Wild)
Hollyleaf isn't evil. I mean, not Tigerstar-evil or Hawkfrost-evil ro Brokenstar-evil type. She just needed more self-control. She was confused, stressed and desperate. An emotional storm like that can really drive a cat crazy.
I am depressed because every friend I know seems to be leaving.*cry* My treasured forum buds are Bramblestar9 (Josh!), Jaydew, *Sunstreak*, Shonee, ~Crystalstar, Spottedspirit21, Dragonpetal, ~x~LightningClaw~x~, Silverwing23, .::Swiftfire::., Hawkstorm13,Firestreak, .Cloverwish, Kestrelcall, RealStar! A Special Message For Bramblestar9: Come back Josh! We miss you
I am depressed because every friend I know seems to be leaving.*cry* My treasured forum buds are Bramblestar9 (Josh!), Jaydew, *Sunstreak*, Shonee, ~Crystalstar, Spottedspirit21, Dragonpetal, ~x~LightningClaw~x~, Silverwing23, .::Swiftfire::., Hawkstorm13,Firestreak, .Cloverwish, Kestrelcall, RealStar! A Special Message For Bramblestar9: Come back Josh! We miss you
I agree Hollyleaf is mentally disturbed. She got shaken by leafpool being her mohter, crowfeather her fauther, squirrelflight and brambleclaw not her parents. She is a good cat I mean she was nice and good in the beginning, she only turned bad after the insidant with the fire which could shake any cat.
I am leaving the forums for good. Goodbye to all my friends on here but a special goodbye to Misty and Kind. I will miss you both!
[Dealt with! - WCM]
"Join Dwindleclan!" "Join Nightpack!"
