In Bluestar's book, she remembers Snowfur rushing her out of the nursery the moment Bluestar opened her eyes. Bluestar remembered this as a warrior.
If Bluestar can remember the moment she opened her eyes perfectly, why can't her kits remember the first few days spent with their mother?
It makes no sense.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Goldenfern,

Ya!

Becasue they were given to oakheart right when they were born probably before they could open there eyes

No, because they opened their eyes and were talking when Bluestar took them to RiverClan.

This is why I dislike the "kits being able to talk right when they are born" thing: plotholes.

THANK YOU!i mean really, ask yourself this question, do you rember your first days of life, so if we don't why should cats?!?!

Well, I doubt that Bluefur and Snowfur actually remember the incident themselves - they were probably told about it by other cats.
Remember that Cloudkit, too, didn't remember his mother either, even though he wasn't taken to the Clan right away when he was born.

quote:

Originally posted by Dawnwing:
Well, I doubt that Bluefur and Snowfur actually remember the incident themselves - they were probably told about it by other cats.
Remember that Cloudkit, too, didn't remember his mother either, even though he wasn't taken to the Clan right away when he was born.

Cloudkit couldn't talk, either!

And kits are supposed to open their eyes about seven days after they are born. Bluestar opened hers one day after she was born AND she could talk! It's crazy!

No its just started when she was opening their eyes it did not say when!

quote:

Originally posted by SongStar:
No its just started when she was opening their eyes it did not say when!

CHAPTER 1, PAGE 5

"Shouldn't she have opened her eyes by now?"

"Hush, Swiftbreeze. She's only a day old."

I was going to ask that question too!

quote:

Originally posted by Jarvey:
This is why I dislike the "kits being able to talk right when they are born" thing: plotholes.

ya i dont like that either. it just goes right from crying balls of fur to bein catish majors!!

b/c they spent so much time in riverclan that they just never remembered. and they only spent their first few days with bluefur. oakheart and graypool could have pursuaded them to believe that teir mother was a loner or rouge who had abandoned them or that graypool and oakheart were their parents all along. kits will believe anything.

But when they were born they knew their mother was bluefur... Maybe their minds were erased!!! LOL!

Even Whitestorm hardly remembered Snowfur. Bluestar asked him toward the end of BP, and he said a little bit, but that was mainly because of having Bluestar around - Bluestar's scent similar to Snowfur's, for one.